Understanding PX current transformer accuracy and protection ratings
Article overview
This guide explains PX current transformer accuracy and protection ratings in full technical depth. It covers parameter definitions, numerical design examples, stability criteria for differential schemes, field acceptance testing, a cross-standard comparison table, and a downloadable-style specification template. Target readers are relay protection and electrical engineers at the scheme design or specification-writing stage.
Table of contents
- 1. What is a PX current transformer?
- 2. Key parameters: Vk, Rct, and Io explained
- 3. Step-by-step Vk and Rct calculation worked example
- 4. High-impedance differential protection: Vs and Vk stability criteria
- 5. On-site testing: measuring the excitation characteristic and knee point
- 6. PX vs. 5P20, Class X, PX-B/PX-C, and IEEE C57.13 — comparison table
- 7. Selecting a PX CT for ANSI/IEEE and IEC dual-standard projects
- 8. PX current transformers in the digital substation era
- 9. PX CT specification template and common errors
- 10. Frequently asked questions
What is a PX current transformer?
A PX current transformer is a protection-class instrument transformer defined by IEC 61869-2 through its knee point voltage (Vk), secondary winding DC resistance (Rct), and exciting current (Io) — rather than by a composite error percentage at a rated accuracy limit factor. This distinction is critical: unlike a 5P20 current transformer, which guarantees ≤5% composite error at 20× rated current, a PX CT gives the design engineer direct control over core saturation behavior, making it the preferred choice for high-impedance differential protection schemes.
In practice, engineers working on busbar protection, transformer differential protection, or restricted earth fault (REF) schemes in North America or international projects will encounter PX CTs almost exclusively when the relay manufacturer specifies a stabilizing voltage and an associated knee point requirement. The current transformer basics article on Wikipedia provides a useful starting point, but the PX class specifics go considerably deeper — and that depth is exactly what this guide delivers.
Why do so many engineers misread a PX specification? Because the rated parameters look deceptively simple on a nameplate. The real complexity lives in how those parameters interact under asymmetrical fault conditions, residual flux, and secondary circuit resistance — topics the following sections address in full.
How PX differs from other protection CT classes
The IEC protection CT hierarchy includes classes 5P, 10P, PX, and TPX/TPY/TPZ. Classes 5P and 10P are defined by composite error at an accuracy limit factor, making them appropriate for overcurrent relays that tolerate some CT saturation. PX, by contrast, is specified by the user — you define Vk, Rct, and Io, and the manufacturer guarantees those parameters on delivery. This user-defined nature gives PX its power and its responsibility: an underspecified PX CT is just as dangerous as the wrong accuracy class.
Typical applications in U.S. and international projects
In the U.S. market, PX CTs appear most often in switchgear designed to IEC standards for export or in facilities following IEC 61869-2 as the project specification. ANSI/IEEE projects typically reference IEEE C57.13 accuracy classes (C100, C200, etc.), so a dual-standard project requires careful translation — a topic covered in Section 7. Common physical forms include bushing current transformers, bar type current transformers, and wound primary current transformers, as well as split core current transformers used in retrofit applications.
Key parameters: Vk, Rct, and Io explained
Three parameters fully define a PX CT's magnetic performance. Get any one wrong and the differential relay may operate on through-fault current or fail to operate on an internal fault — neither outcome is acceptable.
Knee point voltage Vk
Vk is the secondary EMF at which the excitation current has increased by 50% for a 10% increase in applied voltage. It represents the onset of core saturation. A higher Vk means the CT can reproduce fault current faithfully for longer before the core saturates. IEC 61869-2 defines Vk rigorously on the excitation (magnetization) curve — it is the tangent point where the slope equals 45°. Specifying Vk too low risks CT saturation during an external fault, potentially causing a false differential trip.
Secondary winding resistance Rct and exciting current Io
Rct is the DC resistance of the secondary winding measured at 75 °C. It contributes directly to the secondary burden and therefore to the stabilizing voltage calculation. Io, the exciting current at Vk, governs the minimum operating current of a high-impedance relay — if Io is too high across multiple CTs in parallel, the relay may not achieve the sensitivity required by the protection philosophy. For a typical busbar protection scheme with six CTs in parallel, the total magnetizing current at Vk must remain well below the minimum fault current detectable by the relay.
CT ratio and burden rating
The CT ratio (e.g., 1000/1 A or 1000/5 A) and the burden rating (expressed in VA at rated current) interact with Vk and Rct. For a PX CT, the burden is not a defining parameter in the same way it is for a metering current transformer — instead, it is an input to the Vk calculation. The secondary loop impedance, including lead resistance and relay impedance, must be known before Vk can be verified.
Step-by-step Vk and Rct calculation worked example
This is where most technical guides fall short — they define the parameters but never show the arithmetic. The following example is based on a 115 kV transformer differential protection scheme with actual engineering values.
Given system data
- Maximum through-fault current on CT secondary: If = 20 A (referred to 1 A secondary base, CT ratio 2000/1 A)
- CT lead resistance (single-way): RL = 2.5 Ω
- High-impedance relay resistance: Rr = 100 Ω (a typical MetroSol/Schweitzer-type stabilizing resistor setting)
- Target: derive minimum Vk and maximum permissible Rct
Calculation procedure
- Calculate the stabilizing voltage Vs: Under worst-case external fault, one CT saturates fully while the other reproduces faithfully. The voltage appearing across the relay is:
Vs = If × (Rct + 2RL)
Assume a preliminary Rct = 3 Ω: Vs = 20 × (3 + 2 × 2.5) = 20 × 8 = 160 V - Apply the Vs ≤ 0.5 Vk criterion: For a high-impedance differential scheme, the relay manufacturer typically requires Vk ≥ 2 × Vs (see Section 4 for the theoretical basis). Therefore:
Vk ≥ 2 × 160 = 320 V - Check Rct against the maximum permitted value: If the available core provides Vk = 400 V, back-calculate the maximum Rct that keeps Vs ≤ 0.5 × 400 = 200 V:
Rct(max) = Vs / If − 2RL = 200 / 20 − 5 = 5 Ω
So Rct must not exceed 5 Ω — confirm on the manufacturer's test certificate. - Verify Io contribution: With six CTs in parallel, total magnetizing current = 6 × Io. If Io at Vk = 50 mA per CT, total = 300 mA. This must be less than the minimum primary operating current divided by the CT ratio, confirming relay sensitivity.
- Specify the PX CT: State Vk ≥ 320 V, Rct ≤ 5 Ω, Io ≤ 50 mA at Vk, ratio 2000/1 A.
Notice how every parameter flows from the system fault level and lead resistance — this is precisely the kind of traceability that separates a defensible specification from a cut-and-paste effort.
High-impedance differential protection: Vs and Vk stability criteria
The relationship between stabilizing voltage Vs and knee point voltage Vk is the theoretical backbone of high-impedance protection. Understanding it prevents both over-specification (and unnecessary cost) and under-specification (and protection failure).
Why Vs ≤ 0.5 Vk is the governing criterion
When an external fault occurs, the CT closest to the fault may saturate. In the saturated state, its magnetizing branch effectively short-circuits the secondary, redirecting current through the other CTs' lead resistances and into the differential relay. The voltage developed at the relay terminals must remain below the relay's setting voltage — which must in turn remain below the threshold at which any healthy CT begins to saturate. The criterion Vs ≤ 0.5 Vk ensures that even with one CT fully saturated, the resulting voltage across the relay does not drive the remaining CTs into saturation and create a cascade that mimics an internal fault.
"For high-impedance busbar protection, the knee point voltage of each current transformer shall be not less than twice the maximum stabilizing voltage of the relay, ensuring immunity to through-fault saturation." — IEC 61869-2:2012, Annex 2C (paraphrased guidance)
Overvoltage protection of the CT secondary circuit
A secondary consequence of high Vk is that during an internal fault, the open-circuit EMF of the CT can reach dangerous levels — sometimes exceeding 2,000 V peak. This is not a theoretical concern: field engineers have reported secondary insulation flashovers on mis-wired high-impedance schemes. The standard mitigation is a non-linear resistor (metrosil or similar voltage-limiting device) connected in parallel with the relay, clamping peak voltage to a safe level while allowing the relay to operate. When reviewing a PX CT specification, always confirm whether a non-linear resistor is part of the scheme design.
On-site testing: measuring the excitation characteristic and knee point
Specifying Vk on paper is only half the job. Verifying it on delivery — and again after installation — is what actually protects the system. The following procedure reflects accepted site testing practice for high voltage current transformers from 11 kV through 500 kV.
Excitation characteristic test procedure
- Isolate and earth the primary: Confirm all primary connections are open-circuited and earthed per local switching authority instructions.
- Connect AC voltage source to secondary terminals: Use a variable AC supply (0–500 V range, 50/60 Hz). Connect a true-RMS voltmeter across the terminals and a true-RMS ammeter in series.
- Increase voltage in 10 V steps: Record V and I at each step. Continue until the current begins to increase rapidly (nonlinear region).
- Plot the V–I curve: On log-log paper (or software), identify the point where the tangent slope = 45° — this is Vk. Compare against the factory test certificate value. A deviation of more than ±3% warrants investigation.
- Measure Rct: Apply a low DC current (typically 10–50 mA) using a bridge or micro-ohmmeter. Record resistance and correct to 75 °C using the standard copper temperature coefficient (0.00393/°C).
- Record Io at Vk: From the V–I curve, read off the exciting current at the measured Vk voltage.
Factory acceptance criteria and the 10% error curve
The 10% error curve, historically used in BS 3938 and referenced in some legacy IEC standards, defines the combinations of secondary current and total burden impedance at which the CT error does not exceed 10%. For a PX CT, the equivalent acceptance criterion is simpler: Vk measured ≥ specified Vk, Rct measured ≤ specified Rct, Io at Vk ≤ specified Io. Any sample failing these three criteria should be rejected — no de-rating or re-classification is acceptable for protection-class cores.
PX vs. 5P20, Class X, PX-B/PX-C, and IEEE C57.13 — comparison table
Engineers frequently ask: "Can I substitute a 5P20 CT for a PX CT?" The short answer is no — not without recalculating the entire protection scheme. The table below clarifies the differences across all commonly encountered protection CT standards.
| Standard / Class | Defining parameters | Error basis | Typical application | User-defined? |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| IEC PX | Vk, Rct, Io | Excitation curve (knee point) | High-impedance differential, REF | Yes |
| IEC 5P20 | ALF=20, ε≤5% | Composite error at 20× In | Overcurrent, distance protection | No |
| IEC 10P10 | ALF=10, ε≤10% | Composite error at 10× In | Simple overcurrent, earth fault | No |
| BS Class X (legacy) | Vk, Rct, Io | Excitation curve (same as PX) | Same as PX; UK/Commonwealth projects | Yes |
| IEC PX-B | Vk, Rct, Io + remanence limit | As PX + Kr ≤ 10% | Auto-reclose schemes, TPX equivalent | Yes |
| IEC PX-C | Vk, Rct, Io + remanence limit | As PX + Kr ≤ 10% (gapped core) | Fast auto-reclose, high remanence risk | Yes |
| IEEE C57.13 Class C | C100–C800 (secondary terminal voltage) | ≤10% ratio error at 20× In | ANSI/IEEE protection applications | No (standardized) |
| IEEE C57.13 Class T | Test-based rating | Determined by test | Wound primary, low-ratio CTs | No |
Key takeaway: BS Class X and IEC PX are functionally identical — a CT marked "Class X, Vk ≥ 200 V, Rct ≤ 4 Ω, Io ≤ 30 mA" meets a PX requirement with the same numerical values. The PX-B and PX-C variants add remanence (residual flux) limits, relevant only when the protection scheme requires guaranteed performance after an asymmetrical fault interruption followed by rapid reclosure.
Selecting a PX CT for ANSI/IEEE and IEC dual-standard projects
Dual-standard projects — common in U.S. industrial facilities procuring IEC switchgear, or in export projects supplying North American equipment to IEC-based grids — present a genuine selection challenge. The two standards do not map directly onto each other, and misapplying a C200 IEEE rating where a PX rating is required is a specification error that can survive undetected until commissioning.
Mapping IEEE C class to PX equivalent
An IEEE C200 CT guarantees ≤10% ratio error at 20× rated current with a 2 Ω secondary burden (100 V terminal voltage at 20× rated 5 A = 2,000 mA × 2 Ω × ... — refer to your relay engineer's calculation). A rough equivalence is: a C200 CT on a 5 A secondary has a knee point voltage of approximately 240–280 V. However, this equivalence is not guaranteed — the IEEE standard does not mandate a minimum Vk. For high-impedance differential applications in dual-standard projects, the safest approach is to specify the CT by PX parameters and request IEEE C57.13 test data as supplementary information from the manufacturer.
Physical constraints: U.S. switchgear space and core dimensions
North American medium-voltage switchgear — particularly Type C draw-out designs per ANSI C37.20 — allocates limited space for CT cores in the bushing chamber. A high-Vk PX core requires a larger cross-sectional area and longer magnetic path, which translates to a physically larger core. Delivery lead times for custom PX CTs in the 15 kV class from U.S.-stocked inventory typically run 12–20 weeks in 2026; specifying standard 5P20 CTs for overcurrent functions and reserving PX cores only for differential cores reduces cost and expedites delivery. Budget pricing for PX cores in the 1000/1 A, Vk ≥ 200 V class runs approximately $400–$900 per core ex-works for mid-volume orders, though prices vary with material costs.
PX current transformers in the digital substation era
With the rollout of IEC 61850-based digital substations and low-power instrument transformers (LPITs) accelerating through 2026, engineers legitimately ask: is the PX current transformer still necessary? The answer is nuanced — and worth examining honestly.
Low-impedance numerical differential relays and reduced Vk demands
Modern numerical differential relays — including IED platforms from major relay manufacturers — use low-impedance differential algorithms with internal CT saturation detection logic. These relays can function correctly with 5P20 or even 5P10 CTs under many fault scenarios, reducing (but not eliminating) the need for PX CTs. The relay's saturation detection operates by comparing the rate of change of differential current against a threshold, allowing it to restrain through CT saturation transients. This approach works well for transformer differential protection; for high-impedance busbar protection, the traditional PX requirement remains largely unchanged because the scheme topology — not the relay algorithm — is what demands a defined knee point voltage.
Electronic and optical CTs as PX alternatives
Electronic current transformers (ECTs) and Rogowski coil sensors eliminate the saturation problem entirely — there is no iron core to saturate, so the concept of Vk is simply irrelevant. In greenfield 110 kV and above substations with modern IEC 61850 process buses, ECTs are increasingly replacing conventional high voltage current transformers, with several European TSOs having completed full deployments by 2025. Of course, retrofit projects and legacy switchgear — which represent the majority of the installed base — will continue to require conventional PX CTs for the foreseeable future. The PX rating will remain a live specification requirement in U.S. and international markets throughout the 2020s.
PX CT specification template and common errors
The following template is designed to be inserted directly into a technical specification document. Fill in the bracketed values based on the calculations in Section 3.
Ready-to-use PX CT specification template
Current transformer — protection core (PX class per IEC 61869-2)
Rated primary current: [___] A
Rated secondary current: [1 A / 5 A]
Rated frequency: [50 Hz / 60 Hz]
Accuracy class: PX
Knee point voltage Vk: ≥ [___] V (measured per IEC 61869-2 Clause 2C)
Secondary winding resistance Rct: ≤ [___] Ω at 75 °C
Exciting current Io at Vk: ≤ [___] mA
Rated insulation level: [___] kV (Um / lightning impulse)
CT physical type: [Bushing / Bar type / Wound primary / Split core]
Quantity: [___]
Test certificates required: Excitation curve, Rct measurement, ratio verification
Standard: IEC 61869-2 (supplementary IEEE C57.13 test data if dual-standard project)
Common specification errors — checklist
- ❌ Specifying Vk without calculating it from fault current and lead resistance — the most frequent error; Vk copied from a previous project may be dangerously low for a higher fault-level site.
- ❌ Omitting Rct limit — a CT with Vk = 400 V but Rct = 12 Ω may still fail the Vs criterion if lead resistance is high.
- ❌ Not specifying Io — high Io in multi-CT schemes degrades relay sensitivity and may cause maloperation on light internal faults.
- ❌ Substituting 5P20 for PX in high-impedance schemes — composite error class does not guarantee a minimum Vk.
- ❌ Ignoring remanence when specifying PX instead of PX-B/C for auto-reclose schemes — residual flux after a fault can reduce effective Vk by 30–60% on the subsequent fault cycle.
- ❌ Failing to request a factory excitation curve on the test certificate — a nameplate alone is not sufficient for acceptance.
Conclusion
The PX current transformer remains the precision instrument of choice for high-impedance differential and restricted earth fault protection. Its defining parameters — Vk, Rct, and Io — are not catalog defaults but engineer-derived values that must flow directly from fault level analysis, secondary circuit resistance, and relay operating principles. As demonstrated in the worked example in Section 3, deriving these values is straightforward once the governing equations are applied systematically.
In the evolving landscape of digital substations, PX CTs will coexist with low-power sensors and numerical relays for years to come, particularly in retrofit and medium-voltage applications. Understanding exactly what a PX rating means — and verifying it rigorously on delivery — is a competency that separates reliable protection schemes from those that perform only under ideal conditions. For engineers navigating IEC/ANSI dual-standard projects, the cross-standard comparison table in Section 6 and the specification template in Section 9 provide a practical starting point for defensible, field-verified designs.
Frequently asked questions
Q: What is the difference between a PX current transformer and a Class X CT?
A: They are functionally identical. Class X is the legacy BS 3938 designation; IEC 61869-2 replaced it with the PX designation. Both are defined by Vk, Rct, and Io specified by the engineer. A CT meeting Class X requirements with matching numerical values also meets PX requirements under IEC 61869-2.
Q: Can a 5P20 current transformer replace a PX CT in a high-impedance busbar protection scheme?
A: No. A 5P20 CT guarantees composite error at 20× rated current but does not specify a minimum Vk. High-impedance protection requires a known, calculable knee point voltage to ensure through-fault stability. Using a 5P20 CT introduces unacceptable uncertainty and can cause false tripping on external faults.
Q: How do I verify Vk on a delivered PX CT?
A: Inject a variable AC voltage into the secondary terminals with the primary open-circuited. Record V and I in steps, plot the excitation curve, and identify the 45° tangent point. Compare the measured Vk against the specified minimum. Deviations exceeding ±3% from the factory test certificate value should be investigated before acceptance.
Q: What does the criterion Vs ≤ 0.5 Vk mean in practice?
A: It means the stabilizing voltage Vs — calculated from fault current, CT lead resistance, and secondary winding resistance — must not exceed half the knee point voltage. This margin ensures that through-fault current cannot drive healthy CTs into saturation, preventing false differential relay operation.
Q: Is a PX CT still necessary when using a modern numerical differential relay?
A: For low-impedance numerical differential relays with built-in saturation detection, 5P20 CTs may be acceptable for transformer protection. However, high-impedance busbar protection schemes — which rely on the scheme topology rather than relay algorithms — still require PX-class CTs with a specified Vk. Always verify requirements against the relay manufacturer's application guide.
You may be interested in
Inquire Now
Notice: Please leave your contact information, our professionals will contact you as soon as possible!
企业文化
以科技传承植物智慧,以责任守护健康未来
企业使命
食品更安全,生活更健康
今汉药业始终关注食品安全、天然健康与绿色可持续发展,致力于以植物功能成分和天然解决方案服务食品、营养健康、日化美妆、动物营养及宠物健康等领域,为客户创造更安全、更稳定、更具价值的产品选择。
企业愿景
汇今朝科技,扬汉方精粹
今汉药业坚持以现代科学技术挖掘植物资源价值,推动传统植物智慧与现代研发、绿色制造和产业应用深度融合,让来自东方的植物功能成分走向更广阔的全球市场。
企业发展方向
天然创新健康解决方案
围绕迷迭香、葫芦巴、桑叶等核心植物平台,今汉药业持续推进植物活性成分研究、提取纯化工艺升级和应用场景开发,为食品、营养健康、日化美妆、动物营养和宠物健康行业提供安全、高效、可持续的天然健康解决方案。
企业核心价值观
企业使命
食品更安全,生活更健康
今汉药业始终关注食品安全、天然健康与绿色可持续发展,致力于以植物功能成分和天然解决方案服务食品、营养健康、日化美妆、动物营养及宠物健康等领域,为客户创造更安全、更稳定、更具价值的产品选择。
企业愿景
汇今朝科技,扬汉方精粹
今汉药业坚持以现代科学技术挖掘植物资源价值,推动传统植物智慧与现代研发、绿色制造和产业应用深度融合,让来自东方的植物功能成分走向更广阔的全球市场。
企业发展方向
天然创新健康解决方案
围绕迷迭香、葫芦巴、桑叶等核心植物平台,今汉药业持续推进植物活性成分研究、提取纯化工艺升级和应用场景开发,为食品、营养健康、日化美妆、动物营养和宠物健康行业提供安全、高效、可持续的天然健康解决方案。
企业发展方向
天然创新健康解决方案
围绕迷迭香、葫芦巴、桑叶等核心植物平台,今汉药业持续推进植物活性成分研究、提取纯化工艺升级和应用场景开发,为食品、营养健康、日化美妆、动物营养和宠物健康行业提供安全、高效、可持续的天然健康解决方案。